Higher Rates Would Not Help All Four Big Banks Equally

Another Federal Reserve rate increase could lift bank margins, but historical returns and current disclosures show very different sensitivities at JPMorgan, Bank of America, Goldman Sachs and Citigroup.
The Federal Reserve's September decision raised the federal funds target range by 25 basis points to 3.75% to 4.00%. The next scheduled decision comes on December 9, after a two-day meeting. Another increase would not help every large bank equally, and it would not be a free benefit for any of them.
Higher rates can widen a bank's net interest margin when loans and securities reprice faster than deposits. The gain shrinks if customers move cash into higher-yielding products, credit losses rise, or older fixed-rate securities lose value. The backdrop still gives the Fed room to stay restrictive: the Bureau of Economic Analysis reported that September headline PCE inflation was 3.6% from a year earlier and core PCE inflation was 3.1%.
History shows why investors should avoid treating a rate increase as a blanket bank catalyst. A 24/7 Wall St. comparison measured dividend-adjusted share returns from the month-end before each cycle's first increase through the month-end of its final increase. JPMorgan gained 22.6% in 2004 to 2006, 57.7% in 2015 to 2018 and 16.8% in 2022 to 2023. Bank of America returned 26.9%, 48.9% and negative 24.8% across those same cycles. Goldman Sachs returned 63.2%, negative 8.4% and 8.6%, while Citigroup returned 12.2%, 0.7% and negative 15.2%. The comparison is descriptive, not a forecast, because each cycle had different credit, market and regulatory conditions.
JPMorgan has the most consistent record of the four, and its current earnings base is strong. The bank reported third-quarter managed revenue of $50.9 billion and earnings per share of $5.57. Management's central case for 2027 net interest income excluding Markets is about $107 billion, with the forward rate curve contributing to that outlook. The risk is that a longer tightening cycle could weaken employment and consumer credit, turning part of the margin benefit into higher charge-offs.
Bank of America offers a more explicit rate sensitivity. Its third-quarter net interest income was $16.4 billion, up $1.2 billion, or 8%, from a year earlier. The bank's September 30 filing estimated that an immediate parallel increase of 100 basis points in rates would add about $1.4 billion to net interest income over the following 12 months. A 100-basis-point decline would reduce it by about $1.9 billion. Those figures show meaningful exposure, but they also assume a simplified rate move and cannot capture every change in deposit behavior. Higher yields can also reduce the value of fixed-rate securities and pressure accumulated other comprehensive income.
Goldman Sachs is a different case because trading, financing and investment banking matter more than traditional loan spreads. The firm reported third-quarter net revenue of $18.68 billion, net earnings of $5.29 billion, earnings per share of $17.01 and return on equity of 18.7%. More market activity can help its franchises, but abrupt moves can hurt risk appetite, financing conditions and asset values. Its mixed performance across prior hiking cycles fits that less direct relationship.
Citigroup's third-quarter results also point to a more complicated exposure. The bank reported net income of $5.2 billion, earnings per share of $2.85 and revenue of $23.8 billion. Services revenue rose 15%, and return on tangible common equity reached 11.5%. Management has said much of Citi's rate sensitivity sits outside the United States in Services, so foreign rate paths and deposit competition matter alongside the Fed.
The useful question is not simply whether the Fed raises rates on December 9. Investors should compare deposit costs with loan yields, watch card charge-offs and other credit indicators, and track how securities valuations affect capital. JPMorgan's three-cycle record is the strongest, Bank of America has the clearest disclosed rate lever, Goldman depends more on market activity, and Citi has more international sensitivity. Another increase could help earnings, but the benefit will depend on how each bank funds itself and what happens to credit quality.
Continue your BAC research
Image references: · Actual Chase Novi branch photograph via public business listing (Reference copyright retained by its owner; factual visual research, no CC grant claimed.)



