Skip to main content
Be The Investor
BTI Market Newsstocks
Back to News

Etsy's Buyer Growth Narrows Shopify's Advantage, but the Models Differ

Etsy's Buyer Growth Narrows Shopify's Advantage, but the Models Differ

Etsy returned active buyers to growth and expanded its adjusted EBITDA margin, while Shopify grew much faster. The valuation gap reflects a turnaround story versus a premium platform.

Etsy and Shopify both reported stronger businesses in the third quarter, but they are solving different problems. Etsy is trying to prove that its marketplace can grow again. Shopify is trying to sustain rapid expansion while a richer mix of merchant services puts pressure on gross-profit growth.

Etsy's marketplace gross merchandise sales reached $2.65 billion, up 8.8% from a year earlier and 9.1% in constant currency. Active buyers increased 1% to about 87.5 million, the first year-over-year gain in two years. Gross merchandise sales per buyer rose 3.9% on a trailing-12-month basis, although purchase frequency remained modestly lower.

Revenue increased 10.9% to $692.5 million. Adjusted EBITDA rose 14.6% to $210.4 million, lifting the adjusted margin to 30.4% from 29.4%. Those are non-GAAP measures, but they show that the marketplace's return to growth did not require a lower adjusted margin. Etsy also repurchased $394.6 million of stock during the quarter.

Loading market context

Shopify grew much faster. Revenue rose 32% to $3.742 billion and gross merchandise volume climbed about 29% to $119.1 billion. Operating income increased 66%, and free-cash-flow margin reached 22%. Its scale and growth rate justify a higher valuation, but the premium also creates more sensitivity to small misses.

The comparison should not reduce both companies to a single earnings multiple. Etsy operates a marketplace focused on unique and creative goods, with growth tied to buyer acquisition, retention and spending per buyer. Shopify supplies commerce infrastructure to merchants and earns from subscriptions, payments and other merchant services. Shopify's merchant-solutions mix can lift revenue while reducing the consolidated gross-profit rate.

Etsy's fourth-quarter outlook calls for gross merchandise sales growth of 5% to 7%. That is a meaningful test because the third quarter was the first sustained evidence that active buyers had turned positive. If buyer growth stalls again, the lower valuation may prove to be a warning rather than an opportunity.

Shopify's test is different. Management expects low-thirties revenue growth in the fourth quarter, while gross-profit dollars grow in the high twenties. Investors need to see whether operating leverage and cash generation can offset that mix pressure.

Etsy currently offers the clearer turnaround setup, while Shopify offers the stronger growth platform. The decision is not simply cheap versus expensive. It is whether Etsy can make renewed buyer growth durable, and whether Shopify can keep converting premium growth into cash without allowing lower-margin services to dilute the economics.

Continue your SHOP research

Image references: · Jingwei Studio / Andrew Freeman, original Etsy 117 Adams Street entrance design documentation (Reference copyright retained by its owner; factual visual research, no CC grant claimed.)

Frequently asked questions

What is "Etsy's Buyer Growth Narrows Shopify's Advantage, but the Models Differ" about?

Etsy's active buyers returned to growth while Shopify expanded much faster, creating a choice between a turnaround and a premium platform.

Which stocks and assets does this article cover?

This article relates to SHOP.

What is the market context?

Etsy and Shopify both reported stronger businesses in the third quarter, but they are solving different problems. Etsy is trying to prove that its marketplace can grow again. Shopify is trying to sustain rapid expansion while a richer mix of merchant services puts pressure on gross-profit growth. Etsy's marketplace gross merchandise sales reached $2.65 billion, up 8.8% from a year earlier and…

When was this article published?

It was published on 04 / 11 / 2026 by Be The Investor Research.